AP Success - AP US History: James Madison on the Infrastructure Bill
James Madison, the fourth president of the United States, is discussing the Cumberland Road and an infrastructure bill passed in the last session of Congress.
The Cumberland road having been a measure taken during the administration of Mr. Jefferson... I suspect that the question of Constitutionality was but slightly if at all examined by the former, and that the Executive assent was doubtingly or hastily given... the case is distinguished from that now before Congress, by the circumstances 1. that the road was undertaken essentially for the accomodation of a portion of the Country, with respect to which Congress have a general power not applicable to other portions. 2. that the funds appropriated and which alone have been applied, were also under a general power of Congress, not applicable to other funds... Serious danger seems to be threatened to the genuine sense of the Constitution, not only by an unwarrantable latitude of construction, but by the use made of precedents which can not be supposed to have had, in the view of their authors, the bearing contended for... Another and perhaps a greater danger is to be apprehended from the influence which the usefulness & popularity of measures may have on questions of their Constitutionality. It is difficult to conceive that any thing short of that influence could have overcome the constitutional and other objections to the Bill on roads and canals which passed the two Houses at the last Session.
"James Madison to James Monroe, 27 December 1817." National Archives.
Question 1
Briefly identify one opinion regarding the federal government's power expressed in the excerpt.
Question 2
Briefly identify one economic trend that influenced the conflict expressed in the excerpt.
Question 3
Briefly explain one way infrastructure projects affected the American economy in the early 19th century.
Teach with AI superpowers
Why teachers love Class Companion
Import assignments to get started in no time.
Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.
Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.